Feedback 1day cup 01/10

I would like to hear everybody's opinion in this first 1day Cup, about rules, maps, anything.

Some things that I think need change are:

30min/match is not enough, we need to increase this to 40 or 45.
Insert a little break before the final, so that no team has to play 2 matches right after eachother.

- 15 minutes of a break or warm-up before the final should be an option for both teams participating in the final.
- 40 minutes per game yes, but with next teams waiting in case something ends sooner.
- If last kill is in game time, it's a point for the killer provided he's not the defender even if game says timeout (prevents an exploit).
- 1Day formula works much better than prolonged leagues.

Now a suggestion, how about playing more maps but with less rounds? 4 maps till one team reaches score of 3 for example.

i agree with donnie's suggestions except the last one...when a weak team plays against a strong one in the worst scenario(for the weak team)they will play 14 rounds with the current format,but with donnies suggestion will play just 9 rounds .

and what about to play TDM instead of Br?each team will choose one map and they will play for 15 min per map.i havent played TDM yet so i dont know if the others cowboys like this idea.

Yeah TDM-Clanwars remember me of the ole Churchmen times. I think it would be a great idea to have some rounds of TDM in a cup or maybe a TDM-Cup (or Duel-cup or cups 1vs1 (on small maps) like in quake...))? I think there are many SG-Players (also good one!) out there who don`t like BR and so don`t join clans etc. And DM is just another part of sg also some players don`t take it serious. Like in other games like quake-arena or so where DM-cups are popular - why not in SG? I would welcome it - i think it would enrich the sg-scene.

If there is enough interest for TDM we can play that.
But, I really don't think TDM in clanmatches will be fun, because you can buy weapons anywhere. This means that it could be very easy to win by camping in a easy spot.
If it would have spawnable weapons like quake, it would be nice imo.

yes i agree - i don`t thought about this issue - hmmm - but with enough dynamite we can solve this problem? - I don`t know

i think that 1 day cup could be played once a month or maybe even every 2-3 weeks. This could make SG community bigger and more involved. Making a clan and playing in league is longterm issue and making 3 people team for one day is much easier. There are a lot of people playing sg who don't have time for clans but who i think would like to play such a cup from time to time. So making this cup a regular event will probably make more more clans in future.

we don't have enough admins to be running a cup every month

Then make some more admins? I can think of a number of reliable and trustworthy people.

SmokeyBacon wrote:Then make some more admins? I can think of a number of reliable and trustworthy people.

I haven't received any applications for months

No feedback about the maplist?
Imo its good and I haven't heard any complaints.

Maybe its best to review it when we have 1.1 with some new maps.

Oh yeah, sure, im really looking forward to play Lake or Train as a br or this new map by Plates
I guess That'll be fun!